Sunday, 4 October 2020

Felix Joubert (1872-1953) [II]: Collector?

Felix Joubert dressed as a medieval soldier
[Source]

In last week's blogpost we met Felix Joubert, the amazingly talented restorer and copyist of artworks and artefacts in various media. It is probably fair to also label him as a "forger", as he cannot have been unaware that some of his works were intended to deceive: they were either being sold as originals, or used as substitutes for works that were obtained illicitly.

We started our enquiry from the fact that he (or more likely one of his many employees) made a new frame for an illuminated cutting, probably soon after it was sold in the Holford sale in 1927. What I did not mention last week, is that he was also himself the buyer of several lots at that sale. The official  price-list, printed and distributed to catalogue subscribers after the sale, records that he bought lots 1, 2, 9, 14, 25, and 33, for a (substantial) total of nearly £2,200 [1]:

Before I found out who he was, I always assumed that Joubert was a dealer, buying these lots either on behalf of clients, or for stock. This may indeed be true, but I suspect that he was buying at least some items for his own collection, for two reasons.

Lot 1 was a leaf from a mid-13th-century German Psalter, with a very fine full-page miniature divided into two tiers: 

And almost a decade later, in 1936, Hanns Swarzenski recorded its location as "Chelsea, Mr. Joubert (ehem. Holford)." [2]


I suspect that it is no mere coincidence that this miniature includes early depictions of medieval arms and armour, such as two different forms of helmet, and the fastening of a sword-belt:


This would surely have appealed to Joubert, and my supposition is perhaps strengthened by the fact that the next lot bought by Joubert depicts 14th-century armour (albeit in less detail):

but showing clearly the ailettes (rectangular shoulder pieces [Wikipedia]) and leg-armour, including greaves to protect the shins [Wikipedia]:

What undermines my idea that Joubert was a "collector" of miniatures depicting armour is that none of the other lots he bought in this sale seem to do so. Perhaps he was buying the two lots above for himself, and the others for someone else?

In any case, one unexpected benefit of my enquiries about Joubert is that they led me to identify a series of miniatures in the 1838 Ottley sale, one of my ongoing projects.

Although it is not entirely clear from their descriptions, lots 14-18 were apparently all from a single manuscript:

"14    One—A highly finished miniature, representing, in two compartments, David and Goliah [sic], and David and Saul, finely coloured, richly gilt, and in the most perfect preservation"

Now London, BL, Add. MS 60630, fol. 1

"15    One—Another, by the same artist, of Samson and the Lion; and the Slaying of the Philistines"

 Now London, BL, Add. MS. 17864A

"16    One—Another: David playing on the Harp"

 Whereabouts unknown

"17    One—Another: Battle between the Israelites and the Philistines"

 Holford-Joubert: Whereabouts unknown

"18    One—The Almighty with the Symbols of the Evangelists, and on the reverse the Resurrection and Ascension of Christ"

Now London, V&A Museum, 800-1894.


We can now attempt to arrange the miniatures in their original sequence. It seems probable that the V&A leaf, with the Resurrection, Ascension, and Christ in Majesty, was the last leaf of a prefatory cycle:


This would have been followed by the full-page David Harping, which very commonly occupies or faces the Beatus initial of Psalm 1.

One might assume that the Old Testament scenes preceded the Life of Christ ones, but this was not the case. English, Irish, and German Psalters often emphasise the "three fifties" -- the division of the 150 psalms at Psalms 1, 51, and 101 -- with enlarged initials, and sometimes also with miniatures.

BL, Add. MS. 17864A has the end of Psalm 100 on what must be the recto; the miniature with two Samson scenes were therefore on the verso. BL, Add. MS.60630, fol. 1 has the opening words of Psalm 101 on what must have been the verso, and thus its miniature must have been on the recto, facing the Samson scenes: [3]

BL, Add. MS. 17864A

This leaves two more: The David and Goliath leaf and the Holford-Joubert leaf. First, it is worth noting that the Holford-Joubert leaf does not depict the "Battle between the Israelites and the Philistines" as described in the Ottley catalogue, but (as correctly described in the Holford catalogue) The Angel Appearing to Gideon (Judges 6:12-18), and Gideon Defeating the Midianites (Judges 7:19-22).

If the Old Testament narratives scenes were arranged in Biblical order we would expect David and Goliath (1 Samuel) to occur before Gideon (Judges 6-7), which in turn should precede Samson (Judges 14). This we can begin to tentatively reconstruct the arrangement of the Psalter and its miniatures as follows:

Before Psalm 1

  • [Life of Christ scenes, ending with:]
  • Resurrection and Ascension
  • Christ in Majesty
  • David Harping

Before Psalm 51

  • Samson Killing the Lion and Samson Defeating the Philistines
  • David and Goliath and David and Saul

 Before Psalm 101

  • The Angel Appearing to Gideon and Gideon Defeating the Midianites

 

The identified miniatures are all in very good condition. It seems very likely that other miniatures from the same manuscript, and perhaps also text pages, still await recognition.



[1] It is always hard to judge the relative value of historic prices, but here is one benchmark: on the day of the Holford sale, 12 July 1927, The Times newspaper carried an advertisement for Humber cars [Wikipedia]. The cheapest models included a 4-seater Tourer at £267 7s, and the most expensive was a 5-7 seater convertible Saloon Limousine at £1,030. So The £2,200 that Joubert spent at the Holford sale could have bought two top-of-the-range limousines.

[2] Hanns Swarzenski, Die lateinischen illuminierten Handschriften des XIII. Jahrhunderts in den Ländern an Rhein, Main und Donau, 2 vols (Berlin: Deutscher Verein für Kunstwissenschaft, 1936), no. 55.

[3] I cannot show any images of one, or colour images of either, as the BL does not allow readers to photograph illuminated manuscripts.

No comments:

Post a comment

Please include your name